ALBANY – Governor Andrew Cuomo announced a piece of legislation which would give prosecutors the ability to seek proper justice for child sex trafficking victims without the need to put them through the trauma of appearing in court.
New York State law currently requires prosecutors to prove force, fraud or coercion was used to make a child participate in prostitution, which usually requires the testimony of the child victims sought to be protected. Federal law, however, officially recognizes that no child willingly becomes a prostitute.
“This is nothing short of a modern day slave trade that preys on children and the most vulnerable among us and it must be shut down once and for all in New York and beyond,” Cuomo said. “These reforms will close dangerous loopholes in the law that allow these human misery agents go free and will give law enforcement more tools to help protect victims and bring human traffickers to justice.”
Aside from the fact that the idea of children being able to consent to prostitution contradicts other aspects of the law protecting children from sex crimes, the requirement to prove force, fraud or coercion creates a number of problems for prosecutors seeking to convict child sex traffickers.
Further, these victims are frequently convinced that they are in a loving relationship with their trafficker, leading to their refusal to testify or their provision of testimony that they engaged in prostitution out of love and not because of force, fraud or coercion. In these cases, this can result in downgraded charges with lesser sentences than those penalties associated with sex trafficking and the child may then return to the trafficker for the abuse to continue. This program bill adopts legislation previously advanced by Senator Andrew Lanza and Assembly Member Amy Paulin.
The Governor has also directed the Task Force’s youth subcommittee, created in 2016, to work with create action plans to address youth sex trafficking at the local-level in partnership with social service and law enforcement agencies.
The Interagency Task Force on Human Trafficking includes several state agencies, including the Department of Health, Office of Mental Health, Department of Labor, Office of Children and Family Services, Office of Alcoholism and Substance Abuse Services, New York State Office of Victim Services, Office for the Prevention of Domestic Violence, and State Police. The Task Force serves to advise law enforcement agencies and social service organizations on their efforts to detect human trafficking and coordinate appropriate responses. The Task Force helps to provide guidance on protocols and best practices for training and outreach, gathers data, and evaluates approaches to increase public awareness about trafficking.
The Task Force has recently focused on developing training to improve awareness efforts statewide, working to improve collaboration at state, local and federal levels, in order to meet the needs of human trafficking victims. 2016 marked the first year that agencies, other than law enforcement, could submit referrals for confirmation of victims, and as a result, the Office for Temporary and Disability Assistance and the Division of Criminal Justice Services received more than three times the highest previous year in referrals.
In 2017, the pace continued close to the same rate of 2016. The Task Force also contributed to updated basic training for new police officers with respect to human trafficking; completed and disseminated a human trafficking 101 training with accompanying training manual; made significant strides forward with its Youth Subcommittee; improved development of regional human trafficking task forces; and continued to work to keep Task Force members abreast of developments in the field.
Human Trafficking Hotline
If you suspect that you or someone you know may be a victim of human trafficking, call the National Human Trafficking Hotline at 1-888-373-7888 for free and confidential help in 170 languages or text HELP or INFO to BeFree (233733).